Posts In Category Peer Review
Review for What is an upper level ontology?
on May 12, 2010 by Michel Dumontier in Peer Review, Comments (0)
This is a review of What is an upper level ontology? In this article, Robert nicely covers the different aspects that upper level ontologies need to consider to prescribe a […]
Review of What is an ontology?
on February 24, 2010 by dosumis in Peer Review, Comments (0)
This is a review of What is an ontology? by Robert Stevens, Alan Rector and Duncan Hull This article could be split quite neatly in two articles. One is an […]
Review of Automatic Maintenance of Multiple Inheritance Ontologies
on January 23, 2010 by phillord in Peer Review, Comments (0)
This is a review article Comments This is a clear, precise and well-written article describing the topic. It covers the motivation, process and technology of this approach for the development […]
Review of Components of an Ontology
on January 22, 2010 by mikeleganaaranguren in Peer Review, Comments (0)
This is a review of the paper entitled Components of an Ontology, by Phil Lord. This paper describes the three main components that can be found in an ontology (classes, […]
Peer Review of Ontological Annotation of Data
on by Allyson Lister in Peer Review, Comments (0)
This is a peer review of Ontological Annotation Of Data. Overall, this is a very useful resource for people learning about how ontological annotations can be applied to data. There […]
Review of What is an ontology?
on by Michel Dumontier in Peer Review, Comments (0)
This is a review of What is an ontology? This well written article spans both logical and philosophical considerations in Ontology so as to provides insight into the kinds of […]
Review of Reference and Application Ontologies
on by mikeleganaaranguren in Peer Review, Comments (0)
This is a review of the paper Reference and Application Ontologies. This paper describes the difference between reference and application ontologies, especially w.r.t. the motivation for using application ontologies. I […]
Review of Automatic maintenance of multiple inheritance ontologies
on by Simon Jupp in Peer Review, Comments (0)
This is a review of Automatic maintenance of multiple inheritance ontologies. This article provides a concise description of the normalisation process and the examples are clear and well illustrated. The […]
Review of community driven ontology development Authors: Frank Gibson and James Malone
on by Helen Parkinson in Peer Review, Comments (0)
Community Driven Ontology Development Sweeping statement ‘collaboration and community involvement should be maximised within the life-cycle of an ontology‘ – why? Costs vs. benefits. Mixed skill sets, who should be […]
Review of Reference and Application Ontologies
on by Allyson Lister in Peer Review, Comments (0)
This is a review of Reference and Application Ontologies. This article describes what reference ontologies and application ontologies are, and how they can be used together. It is a well-written […]