Uncategorized – Ontogenesis http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org An Ontology Tutorial Thu, 08 Aug 2013 14:03:20 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.2 Nearly all Noticeable virtual data room http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1522 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1522#respond Mon, 21 Jan 2019 15:41:54 +0000 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/?p=1522&preview=true&preview_id=1522

When choosing a password for your data living room, make convinced they have solid adequate together with simple to consider. A records room or space can give you the capacity for assorted folks his job collectively along with write about files which inturn have to be secure regarding assorted elements. An on the internet data living room or exclusive data area is a good online factory associated with significant papers in relation to an institution. Often the internet information room can be guarded simply by security methods that could be made clear in the agreement. A secure data room is most likely going that will be an option in the exact event the exact need is determined that will broadcast information by a single financial institution completely to another. It provides incredible send in addition to receive tips while guarding often the level of privacy in the files. Protect data spaces allow the advantage pertaining to help disclosing the actual comprehensive info together having memory space together diffusion.

Everyone will end up being much more remarkable when you could possibly also deliver to deliver history some sort of data area. The files room in your home helps make it simple to write about important particulars. The internet records living room will be a superb method of package with internet business remotely. It allows often the selling firm to present beneficial tips inside a governed means together with in a means to help save confidentiality.

data room

Intended for bigger businesses, however, the expert products and services of any investment lender usually are necessary to deliver sure a bigger quantity for possible buyers are usually considered in addition to a competitive great deals procedure is usually run. From a day or maybe two with exploitation, you ought to be prepared to be able to company name your own much-loved assistance. The full personal computer grow back providers give by way of observe preferably diminished prices not everybody any kind of other corporation offer the exact same prices assistance.

The Dropped Secret of information Room

Data files room is usually an essential device for due groundwork. Virtual data rooms are also referred so that you can as Cope Rooms. Making use of a digital data files room affords the electronic data room needed safety to let you towards carry out your own company not having fear involving your protection sin or possibly information thieves. It may also present the capability share information. It will be probably the greatest purchases you can create so that you can ensure anyone happen to be swift inside your result in order to effort. It has developed over time for becoming a device in order to enhance the whole option course, definitely not just with regard to to accomplish research. Any digital facts room or digital price room stipulates the functionality to deliver essential papers in addition to data if these people wanted easily.

Innovative Detail by detail Plan intended for Info Room in your home

Quite possibly if the very room is certainly being spotted just for internal reasons like administration about cooperation involving numerous organizations, them is critical to be able to the very actions regarding workers. In particular, you can opt to populate all the living room nevertheless nearby off usage of detailed information for the purposes of first credited diligence. A number of most individuals quite possibly imagine that the particular room is often a costly please. Though multimedia information bedrooms supply quite a few awesome rewards, it’s possibly not suitable intended for all unique corporation. With precisely the same time, the main digital houses are really at ease meant for all personnel and young partners, since it has the use does not have an elaborate understanding train. Eventhough internet records rooms produce many advantages, the item is not really suitable each market place. Some sort of digital deal space , homework space, or perhaps data room in your home can offer you you the entire advantages connected with a record storage capability without wanting to rent payments the external space plus manually organize the docs.

]]>
http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1522/feed 0
1 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1514 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1514#respond Mon, 21 Jan 2019 00:00:00 +0000 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/?p=1514

1

]]>
http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1514/feed 0
Making an internet amount is a lot far more convenient, specially for adult pupils, than attending an on- campus program. http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1520 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1520#respond Thu, 09 Aug 2018 18:51:27 +0000 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/?p=1520&preview=true&preview_id=1520

Here one typically contains the opening parts of the article. The issue will pick the central or main issue of the essay. Furthermore, you will receive to relish writing the article more. Use these formulation to assist you write the perfect article possible. Finding out how to compose documents is a significant component of boosting your communication skills. Obvious debate and tasteful vocabulary are the secrets to success regarding how you can compose superb composition. An essential element of figuring out how exactly to write documents is consistently to comprehend the need for construction. Determine why it’s you’re composing what you are writing. Editing is an essential section of essay writing. The excellent thought that you have to focus up on at first, is the intention paper writings of composing this essay.

His cd wildflowers bought greater than three million clones in the usa.

Here are a few advice on the best way to start writing an essay that could represent your own ideas and personal design. The foremost role in composing this article is going to be to learn more about the play and its characters. The roughest portion of composing an article must be beginning it. Remember how a lot of these documents they are heading to read, you should be sure yours stands out from the group. The closing is effortlessly the most vital part your composition. It really is the most significant part of the essay. Through essay they’re competent to exhibit their potential.

Once you??ve discovered that, start working.

Also don’t believe your professor or instructor will soon be just audience, there’ll be much more readers within the near future who may want to send to your own article. Maintain a constant tone through the whole composition. This educational article furnishes the responses to different questions about composition writing and proposes important methods for students. If you love to truly know the best way to write great article then you must follow the given below tips, it really is aa comprehensive guideline for these beginners who would need to write in the 1st attempt. If you like to understand the way to write strong ; significant composition then you certainly must follow the given below tricks, it really is aa complete guideline for those novices who would like to write excellent documents in the 1st attempt. Today create an abstract which you will utilize as a guide when creating your true essay. The initial and most vital guideline is the fact that the article needs to be in five paragraphs. Repeat for each and every essay fast on the applications you have got. Normally the thesis is located in the very first sentence of the essay.

I am likely to stay here after all, okey doke?” is enough to maintain your location.

A succinct and clear format is able to make your essay simple to compose. Don’t discover wordy or you’ll get stuck in these paragraphs and additionally the body isn’t the most essential part your composition. It’s been established the essay will probably have more pounds in the big event the introduction is composed properly. Should youn’t know the heartbeat, you then’ll ensure a total notion of how to really write the essay. You need to be competent enough to demonstrate within the whole of your own composition that you just’ve followed all of the directions provided in the subject.

]]>
http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1520/feed 0
In reality element of the matter is the amazing selection accessible. http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1516 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1516#respond Tue, 10 Jul 2018 15:08:03 +0000 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/?p=1516&preview=true&preview_id=1516

Also, the instances at which Count rewards those who find themselves good have been decreased from the movie entirely, shedding a vital theme of the novel. I wont make it hard to determine what my point is actually in this composition. For some thing to become a very good persuasive essay topic, it must be an controversial problem. Today get back to your very first creating, and observe if there’s anything you forgot. He knows not just the authors but similarly the a number of other writers who’ve any kind of prejudice. In the event the reader or marker isn’t interested within the first few phrases, odds are they wont examine into what it’s that you’re declaring for the balance of the essay both. Her novella, Anthem (1938) is a quite distinct case of the genre. I need to state I actually like writing too. Pupils may have difficulty in fixing their specific vocation expectations. Stress among college students may come from several resources.

In percent you expect inside the second passage note just how much increment.

Fortunately, it appears to be feasible that low income pupils appear to begin getting help. Obviously, it really is up to a pupil to get the most from their college experience. The utilisation for just one single period contributes to drug addiction. All things considered, nobody claims they would like to be regarded as a drug abuser when they mature. All those are issue you could need to consider if you have to write about medications alcohol and smoking. This might reduce the demand for medicines. When it comes to expiring from a cannabis overdose, there’s n’t any document of any man or girl dying from marijuana.

Pdf stands for doc file that is lightweight, and it’s a general file.

It must be portrayed in a single word before starting. Drug habit is quite harmful to human beings. Addicting medications aren’t merely offered via the drug sellers but they’re very easily obtainable at just about any specific pharmacy. Unique medicines have various consequences. It really is a great method for drug habit. Diamorphine customers must be informed as there are several sorts of heroin going around. The usual denominator is apparently a mix of medications and robbery. As an easy method to test special medications, they desired living things. affordable-papers.net The most contentious types of function contain the military usage of children and child prostitution.

If you wish to make use of less resources, the identical does apply.

Occasionally an alternative material is provided. Whatever becomes hard to read out should to be shifted. Afterwards within the publication, it truly is going to be mentioned how the frontrunners locally can help decrease drug addiction in Huntington. Medication addicts are sick…but might be healed. Besides the truth that bud is among the top 3 drugs that Americans use, other ethnicities around the globe use cannabis everyday. Besides several medi cal uses, grass does not have any wellness advantages. Looking at what you have composed up to now, make a listing of conditions it truly is possible to look up to get articles on your own paper. This striking opinion is an article or maybe a book in itself.

Deliver commitment to workforce jobs and encourage others to produce suggestions.

Here, I should educate you about the best way to write a really effective lines and several examples of focus getters for you next essay! Many pupils don’t even dare have the book to study. Consider for instance this composition will probably be efficiently composed because there’s power to always keep my pc on. This might have an impact on the improvement of pupils within the class. The test offers you a description of someone in that you’ll need to recall afterwards, this is generally a video portion of the exam. The polygraph test is perhaps the most unnerving portion of the entire hiring procedure

]]>
http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1516/feed 0
More schooling translates to another degree. http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1518 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1518#respond Mon, 18 Jun 2018 16:00:56 +0000 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/?p=1518&preview=true&preview_id=1518

Writing a suitable cover for an article you have created is not an extremely ambitious task whatsoever, but it’s the many disregarded. Writing this kind of essay isn’t a straightforward job. For instance if I’m creating a paragraph about’ Personality’. The aim of writing this sort of composition would be to inquire and investigate. Most of us have a tendency to re write frequently, and pupils will have to notice that spinning, and even backtracking, is really a natural area of the process — maybe not an indication they’re making errors. For instance, for anyone who is writing about’ kinds of businesses’, you need to include the present tendencies of the industry world plus a short regarding the income – earning abilities within the introduction. An establishment of the relationship between the rationale and effect has become the most essential portion of an article. This issue is the fact that, when reading such an article, it really is unclear regarding what the student is assessing until near to the judgment.

They’re ideas that might or might not arrived at fruition.

You really do not require to argue for or against this issue you’re composing on. Given below are a couple of key places which could supply themes for composing a superb satire. The perfect portion about creating an insightful article may be the wide range of subjects you are able to pick from. Within this portion of the writeup, we are going to provide you with some tips for writing a excellent reflective article. A new, unique essay matter, on which you’re confident, you are going to be capable enough to assemble plenty of advice, should to be chosen. Here we’re heading to learn more about the different types of process evaluation essay matters which one may write on, as well as the mode to piece together your composition. This checklist deals with quite a few the straightforward to write composition issues.

California law encourages one to post notices the property is under siege.

A finished item is just a part of such procedure. The last step within this procedure is to write the summary. Though that is not a authentic part of your essay, it’s possibly the most crucial within the process. The 1st step inside this process (after choosing a topic ) would be to brainstorm. Without appropriate structure, www affordable-papers net actually superb content cannot save an article. It was an overall statement that is certainly eye catching but nonetheless conveys the overall matter of the essay. This can make the fundamental skeleton and synopsis of your own composition. Use this overall composition construction to produce a detailed outline on your own documents. Often times, conditioned upon the form of essay, the 2nd body section may be used to create a concession and rebuttal.

Use critical verbs like ???buy now???.

You’re also advised to provide a copy of your own descriptive article to your own buddy, teacher or comparable. Instead, the essay needs to be composed in these manner that each one of the paragraphs appear connected to each other. This supports yielding a suitable conclusion to the composition. Start your essay using a thesis statement. This unquestionably is an example of the weak thesis statement since it is overly generic along with obscure. It’s potential for You to brainstorm the topics for an entire document or merely a decision or an instance. To compose on an expository article, you’ll need to assess and inquire in to the advice and also the arguments also, in a magnificent and precise style. At the very first stage, you will need to select a very good theme to your own essay.

Abusive males are often children of neglect themselves.

Only ensure your composition will not seem merely factual. Each expository composition may obtain a definite goal. Discuss the primary idea of the essay.

]]>
http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1518/feed 0
Friends and Family: Exploring Transitivity and Subproperties http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1376 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1376#respond Thu, 08 Aug 2013 14:03:20 +0000 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/?p=1376

Summary

An exploration of the relationship between subproperties and property characteristics, in particular transitivity.

Author

Sean Bechhofer
Information Management Groups
School of Computer Science
University of Manchester
Oxford Road
Manchester
United Kingdom
M13 9PL
sean.bechhofer@manchester.ac.uk

Property Characteristics and Subproperties

Transitive properties can be very useful in ontologies. Recall that a property P is transitive if and only if the following is true:

* For all x, y, and z: P(x,y) and P(y,z) => P(x,z)

An example of a transitive property is “ancestor”. Any ancestor of an ancestor of mine is also an ancestor of mine. OWL provides us with an axiom for stating that a particular property is transitive.

ObjectProperty: ancestor
  Characteristics: Transitive

The notion of subproperties are also useful. For a property Q, R is a subproperty if and only if

* For all x, y: R(x,y) => Q(x,y)

An example of a subproperty relationship is “hasParent” and “hasFather”. Any two individuals that are related via the father relationship must be related via the parent relationship.

ObjectProperty: hasParent

ObjectProperty: hasFather
  SubPropertyOf: hasParent

Sometimes there is confusion over the way in which characteristics like transitivity interact with the sub/super property hierarchy. As far as transitivity is concerned, the characteristic is not “inherited” by sub-properties — we cannot infer that the sub property of a transitive property is transitive. The same holds for super properties.

To illustrate this, consider the following example. We have three (object) properties: knows, hasFriend, marriedTo. One of these (hasFriend) is transitive (now you might question this as a piece of modelling, but please just go with my rosy world-view that all the friends of my friends are also friends), and the properties are arranged in a hierarchy. In Manchester syntax we would have:

ObjectProperty: knows

ObjectProperty: hasFriend
  Characteristics: Transitive
  SubPropertyOf: knows

ObjectProperty: isMarriedTo
  SubPropertyOf: hasFriend

And yes I know that expecting marriage to imply friendship is again hopelessly optimistic, but I’m a hopeless optimist.

Now, consider a domain with four elements, Arthur, Betty, Charlie and Daphne. They are related as follows:

* Arthur knows Betty.

* Betty knows Charlie and Daphne.
* Betty hasFriend Charlie and Daphne.
* Betty isMarriedTo Charlie.

* Charlie knows Daphne.
* Charlie hasFriend Daphne.
* Charlie isMarriedTo Daphne.

The situation is as pictured below.

transitivity

If we look at the ontology presented above, we can see that all the axioms hold — the subproperty axioms are being respected, as is the transitivity of hasFriend. Thus this situation is a model of the ontology.

Now if we consider isMarriedTo, we can see that our conditions for transitivity do not hold. There are three elements with isMarriedTo(Betty,Charlie) and isMarriedTo(Charlie,Daphne), but we do not have isMarriedTo(Betty,Daphne). So we cannot infer that isMarriedTo is transitive from the axioms. Similarly, there are three elements where knows(Arthur,Betty) and knows(Betty,Charlie) but we don’t have knows(Arthur,Charlie).

Recall that the inferences we can make from an ontology or collection of axioms are those things that necessarily hold in all models of the ontology. This little sample model provides us a “witness” for the fact that we cannot infer that knows is transitive from the axioms. Similarly, we cannot infer that isMarriedTo is transitive.

Of course, this is just saying that we can’t in general make such an inference. We are not saying that superproperties cannot (sometimes) be transitive. If we add to our interpretation the fact that Arthur knows Charlie and Daphne, then in this interpretation, knows is indeed transitive. And if we allow Betty to marry Daphne — hey, it’s 2013! — then we have a transitive subproperty (in this interpretation).

On the topic of transitivity and sub properties, the thesaurus representation SKOS uses a common modelling pattern, where a non-transitive property (skos:broader) has a transitive superproperty (skos:broaderTransitive) defined. The superproperty is not intended to be used for asserting relationships, but can be used to query for transitive chains of skos:broader relationships (assuming our query engine is performing inference). As we now know, this doesn’t mean that skos:broader is necessarily transitive.

This pattern is also often used for representing partonomy. Here we would use a (non-transitive) hasDirectPart for asserting parts of a whole, with a transitive superproperty hasPart allowing us to query the transitive closure. We can use counting with hasDirectPart — for example min or max cardinality restrictions — which we would not be able to do in OWL DL if hasDirectPart was transitive, due to restrictions relating to simple properties (see the OWL2 Structural Specification).

For other property characteristics the situation is different. For example, a subproperty of a functional property must be functional. Why? We’ll leave that as an exercise for the interested reader……

]]>
http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1376/feed 0
Review for OWL = http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1093 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1093#comments Fri, 13 May 2011 14:04:54 +0000 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/?p=1093

This is a review for Uli Sattler’s article on OWL the Web Ontology language. The title “OWL” looks a little strange in the table of contents, so I’d be inclined to change it to “The Web Ontology Language (OWL)”. Most of my comments are at this level, so indicates that the article is fine. I have only a few other comments.

As a background to how OWL works this K-Blog works for me. This article takes the reader on an introductory tour of OWL. It gives a genral background on OWL. It concentrates on the reasoning side of OWL – what a reasoner does. A few lines of introduction to say what the purpose the article is and what it wil not do would be useful. for instance, a guide to OWL exspressivity and modelling tips for OWL is not the purpose of this article. A link to Phil Lord’s KBlog on components and Matt Horridge’s on OWL syntax would be good.

Whilst OWL is probably the most prominent ontology language of the moment, within the biology context that is the topic of the Ontogenesis Kblog, the OBOF format should be mentioned (along with a link to the OBOF K-Blog). In this community, OBOF is very widely used and this should be acknowledged.

It would be useful to give a simple statement of what an axiom is. The word “model” and its meaning within the DL world may need more attention as well (or a warning to just overlook it). Model is used in this community in its much more general sense.

“where OWL and reasoning is used purely to make sure that the things said about classes and the resulting entailed class hierarchy are correct” – Is OWL natively used in SnoMED? I thought it used a DL, but not OWL as such. Also, “correct” needs care as it is checked for logical correctnesss rather than domain of interest correctnerss.

Minor:

  • “are important: OWL comes in” → sentence change instead of colon.
  • “, properties, and inviduals” → individuals
  • “chose whatever relation you like” → choose
  • “help us unterstand ” → understand
  • “Coming back to Protege” → new paragraph at onset of this sentence.
  • “currently recides in” → resides
  • “Both have clearly advantages ” clearly have

reviewed by robert Stevens

School of Computer Science, University of Manchester.

]]>
http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/1093/feed 1
Characterising Representation http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/257 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/257#comments Fri, 22 Jan 2010 12:59:24 +0000 http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/?p=257

The word ontology is highly overloaded and can have a number of interpretations. In addition, there a variety of representations, languages and approaches that can be used to represent knowledge. Each has characteristics that impact on their appropriate usage or the functionalities that they offer. The following attempts to tease out some of the differences between the various representation languages and solutions available. Although some of this may be “well known” or obvious, it is useful to set out clearly the vocabulary that we are using — for example, the term formal is often used to refer to languages which are what we have called here semantically strong.

Content by Sean Bechhofer and Robert Stevens.

Representation Languages and Artefacts

In the following discussion, we distinguish between knowledge artefacts and representation languages. A knowledge artefact (or more simply artefact) captures some particular knowledge about a domain. Artefacts are represented using a representation language which provides syntax (and some degree of semantics) for expressing such knowledge. An example of a representation language is OWL [link], while OBI [link], a particular OWL ontology, is an artefact.

This distinction between the languages and the artefacts is important – for example there is a relationship between expressive languages and rich representations, but one does not necessarily always produce rich ontologies when using an expressive language.

Establishing a vocabulary allows us to articulate the characteristics of our representations and artefacts, and assists in placing them within space. This will help in tasks such as choosing appropriate artefacts for particular purposes or evaluation. For example, FMA [link] and MeSH [link] are both artefacts that are referred to as ontologies, but have radically different representation languages, modelling styles and application usages.

Below we set out a number of characteristics that can apply to representation languages and artefacts.

Syntax and Semantics

Representation languages have a syntax — a way of writing statements down. Syntax sets out rules that tell us how to form expressions using the symbols available, and defines what constitutes well formed statements in the language. For example, to use Manchester OWL Syntax:

(X and Y)

is a well-formed class expression, whereas

and X Y()

is not.

Syntax on its own carries no meaning. The syntax rules simply tell us which combinations of symbols are valid. The semantics of the representation language allow us to interpret those combinations of symbols.

Semantic Strength

A strong representation language is one for which explicit semantics are given for the operators or vocabulary of the representation. The semantics tells us what well-formed statements mean, and are often defined as the set of concrete situations (models) that are consistent with a sentence or set of sentences (this is often called a model theory). A strong representation can reduce the ambiguity or vagueness that might be present in determining whether concrete situations are consistent with the statements being made in the vocabulary.

A strong representation language facilitates machine processing via inference (see reasoning).

A weak representation language is one for which explicit (machine-processable) semantics are given for the operators in the language.

For example, to compare OWL and SKOS, OWL is a stronger representation, while SKOS is weaker — the semantics of the OWL subclass relationship are given in terms of class extensions, while in SKOS intended interpretation of the hierarchical and related relationships are given in natural language, viz: A hierarchical link between two concepts indicates that one is in some way more general (“broader”) than the other (“narrower”). An associative link between two concepts indicates that the two are inherently “related”, but that one is not in any way more general than the other. Note that for SKOS, the situation is slightly complicated, as there are some conditions for which a semantics is provided (for example, the broaderTransitive relation is declared to be transitive, which allows some inferences to be drawn).

Note that here the use of the terms “strong” and “weak” are not intended to be used in a pejorative sense. A weaker representation language may be more appropriate than a stronger one in some particular application scenario.

Expressivity

The expressivity of a representation language refers to the ability of the language to distinguish between different kinds of concrete situation. For example, OWL provides different quantifiers that allow us to distinguish between situations where all of the related objects must have some characteristic (universal quantification) and situations where some related object must have a characteristic (existential quantification). Expressivity can be seen as a “sliding scale” — for example, OWL Lite is a less expressive language than OWL DL, as it lacks some of the operators provided in OWL DL (e.g. cardinality restrictions involving numbers other than 1 or 0). Expressivity is related to semantic strength.

There are also differences between languages which are “naturally” and “un-naturally” expressive. For example, negation is not explicitly present in OWL-Lite (there is no complementOf operator, but can be encoded.

Similarly, representation languages may include “syntactic sugar”, for example allowing equivalence axioms between class expressions rather than requiring explicit pairs of subclass axioms.

Cognitive complexity. Do I need to write down a lot in order to express something?

Reasoning

Reasoning refers to the process of answering some semantic based query, such as determining if one statement follows from another. Reasoning is generally performed in the context of a particular artefact, using the characteristics or properties of the representation language (for example the semantics). Reasoning thus relies on a strong representation (e.g. the representation has a semantics that can be used as the basis for that reasoning). Issues of tractability and scalability (related to expressiveness and richness). [Link to elsewhere]

Formality (artefact)

A formal ontology is an artefact in which certain philosophical principles have been applied in order to determine that the underlying content is an “accurate” or faithful representation of the world. Formality is a property of an artefact. There are a number of mechanisms and methodologies for ensuring formality (e.g. OntoClean). Upper ontologies can be used in order to ensure that the organisation of the ontology is consistent with other ontologies (rather than ad hoc). The use of an upper ontology is likely to lead to increased formality.

Formality requires a subjective, qualitative judgement. This may also depends on the ontological modelling style.

Axiomatic Richness (artefact)

The axiomatic richness of an artefact refers to the level of axiomatisation that is present. The term axiomatisation is taken to refer to the expression, in some representation language, of the explicit assumptions being made about the domain described by the artefact. A lack of axiomatic richness limits the possibility of deriving inferences from an artefact. There are no guarantees, however, that an artefact that is axiomatically rich will lead to many new inferences.

Axiomatic richness could be measured in a number of ways. Hayes [ref] for example, in the Naive Physics Manifesto, discusses density. One could also consider coverage, i.e. how much information is being captured about the domain.

Knowledge artefacts may include rich descriptions of their content in terms of natural language descriptions, scope notes etc. For example, a SKOS vocabulary with very detailed descriptions of the Concepts described in it. Such an artefact would not necessarily be considered axiomatically rich: although the artefact contains comprehensive information, this is not being presented in a form amenable to machine processing.

Application/Purpose (artefact)

What is the intended purpose of the artefact? How is it actually used (this could differ from the intended purpose)? Who are the intended consumers? Humans? Machines?

Community/Consensus (artefact)

Does the artefact capture the view of an individual or a community?

Cost

Cost applies to both representation languages and artefacts. Costs are incurred in a number of ways.

  • Computational costs (time, space, memory). Cost of reasoning. Related to expressivity, axiomatic richness.
  • Cognitive costs. Understanding a language can be challenging. The articulation of facts using a representation can be difficult.
  • Management costs. Construction, maintenance, change management, all of which can be hard in collaborative situations.

Examples

This section requires further work.

Language Strength Expressivity
OWL Strong high expressivity
SKOS Weak low expressivity
RDF(S) Strong low expressivity
RDF Weak ?? (it’s just a carrier syntax)

Artefact examples?

  • GALEN
  • MeSH
  • OBI
  • FMA
  • GO

Non-rich OWL, something that respects the semantics — there are things around that have been “bent” into OWL, and which thus doesn’t respect the semantics. There is a difference between things that shouldn’t be represented as OWL, because they don’t respect the semantics and things which could be represented as OWL, but there’s no point because they’re not rich enough.

Acknowledgements

This paper is an open access work distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 3.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided that the original author and source are attributed.

The paper and its publication environment form part of the work of the Ontogenesis Network, supported by EPSRC grant EP/E021352/1.

]]>
http://ontogenesis.knowledgeblog.org/257/feed 1